Cities around the world trying to limit driving have faced objections � namely that the measures would limit personal freedom, cost too much, destroy commerce or have negligible effects on air quality.
Now the first data from these experiments in New York, London and Paris is trickling in. They offer some clues about whether cutting speed limits, charging traffic for entering a city center and penalizing drivers of the most polluting cars can reduce congestion and improve air quality, without causing too much disruption.
kAm%96D6 =6DD@?D 2C6 96=A7F= 3642FD6 4:E:6D[ H96C6 AC@3=6>D H:E9 EC277:4 2?5 A@@C 2:C BF2=:EJ 2C6 7C6BF6?E=J >@C6 D6G6C6 E92? :? =6DD FC32? 2C62D[ 2C6 @7E6? >@G:?8 >@C6 BF:4<=J :? C6DEC:4E:?8 G69:4=6 6>:DD:@?D E92? 4@F?EC:6D @C DE2E6D] x? tFC@A6[ 4:E:6D 2C6 @FEA24:?8 =2HD 2?5 ?2E:@?2= C68F=2E:@?D E@ 4FE EC277:4 A@==FE:@?[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 E9:?< E2?< %C2?DA@CE U2>Aj t?G:C@?>6?E] x? E@E2=[ bd 4:E:6D 92G6 4@>>:EE65 E@ :?EC@5F4:?8 “K6C@ 6>:DD:@?D K@?6D� � H96C6 5:6D6= 2?5 82D@=:?6\A@H6C65 G69:4=6D H:== 36 32??65]k^Am
kAm$E:==[ 62C=J C6DF=ED 7C@> D@>6 4:E:6D D9@H C65F4:?8 EC277:4 :D ?@E 6?@F89] %2<6 ~D=@[ H9:49 92D A:@?66C65 =@H6C DA665 =:>:ED[ 42C\7C66 K@?6D 2?5 :>AC@G6>6?ED E@ AF3=:4 EC2?DA@CE[ H2=<:?8 2?5 4J4=:?8] }@CH2J’D H:56DAC625 25@AE:@? @7 6=64EC:4 42CD 92D 2=D@ 96=A65 C65F46 D>@8] qFE E96 4:EJ DE:== DF776CD 7C@> 9:89 =6G6=D @7 A2CE:4F=2E6 A@==FE:@? 7C@> E:C6 H62C[ H@@5\3FC?:?8 DE@G6D 2?5 5FDE 7C@> 8C2G6= 2?5 D2=E:?8 @? :4J C@25D]k^Am
kAm(9:=6 C6DEC:4E:?8 7@DD:=\7F6=65 G69:4=6D H@?’E D@=G6 E9@D6 AC@3=6>D[ E96C6 :D 6G:56?46 E92E :E 96=AD 4=62? E96 2:C 2?5 92D @E96C 36?67:ED E@@]k^Am
kAmw6C6’D H92E A@=:4J >2<6CD 2?5 4:EJ 5H6==6CD 42? =62C? 7C@> @E96C 62C=J 25@AE6CD]k^Am
k9cm}6H *@C<k^9cm
kAm%96 4:EJ :?EC@5F465 2 A@=:4J @? y2?] d 492C8:?8 42CD FA E@ Sh 2 52J E@ 6?E6C 46CE2:? A2CED @7 |2?92EE2?] %C2G6= E:>6 52E2 7C@> E96 7:CDE E9C66 >@?E9D @7 E96 492C8:?8 K@?6 DF886DED 4@>>FE:?8 E:>6D 2C6 5@H? @? D@>6 @7 E96 3FD:6DE C@FE6D[ :? A2CE:4F=2C E96 3C:586D 2?5 EF??6=D E92E 4@??64E |2?92EE2? H:E9 }6H y6CD6J[ qC@@<=J? 2?5 "F66?D]k^Am
kAmp D:E6 CF? 3J DEF56?E 3C@E96CD y@D9F2 2?5 q6?;2>:? |@D96D 92D 366? EC24<:?8 EC2G6= E:>6D 32D65 @? v@@8=6 |2AD EC277:4 52E2 @? G2C:@FD C@FE6D 27764E65 3J E96 }6H *@C< 4@?86DE:@? AC:4:?8 D:?46 E96 A@=:4J H2D :?EC@5F465 :? y2?F2CJ] %96J 7@F?5 EC2G6= E:>6D 92G6 2=D@ 5C@AA65 5FC:?8 H66<6?5D[ H9:=6 E96C6’D 366? =:EE=6 492?86 @? @E96C C@FE6D 8@:?8 7C@> @?6 A2CE @7 |2?92EE2? E@ 2?@E96C] %92E DF886DED A6@A=6 2C6 49@@D:?8 E@ E2<6 AF3=:4 EC2?DA@CE @C 4FEE:?8 @FE =6DD FC86?E EC2G6=[ E96J D2J]k^Am
kAmx? q@DE@? 2?5 r9:428@[ H9:49 E96 |@D96D FD6 2D 2 4@?EC@=[ EC277:4 =6G6=D 92G6 ?@E 492?865 D:8?:7:42?E=J] p D6A2C2E6 C6G:6H C6=62D65 :? y2?F2CJ 3J E96 EC277:4 52E2 AC@G:56C x?C:I 649@6D E96:C 7:?5:?8D[ H9:=6 2 q=@@>36C8 2?2=JD:D C6=62D65 2C@F?5 E96 D2>6 E:>6 7@F?5 76H6C AC:G2E6 42CD 2?5 >@C6 E2I:D @? E96 C@25]k^Am
k9cm!2C:Dk^9cm
kAm|2J@C p??6 w:52=8@ :?EC@5F465 d_<A9 Wb_ >A9X DA665 =:>:ED @? E96 4:EJ’D @FE6C C:?8 C@25 :? ~4E@36C[ 56DA:E6 @AA@D:E:@? 7C@> uC2?46’D EC2?DA@CE >:?:DE6C 2?5 4@?D6CG2E:G6 @AA@?6?ED]k^Am
kAmp C6A@CE 7C@> E96 4:EJ’D FC32? A=2??:?8 56A2CE>6?E 7@F?5 E92E E96 ?6H[ =@H6C DA665 =:>:E[ :?EC@5F465 @? ~4E] ` =2DE J62C[ 92D 2=C625J 925 D@>6 A@D:E:G6 67764ED] x? E96 7@==@H:?8 7:G6 >@?E9D[ 2:C BF2=:EJ :>AC@G65 3J `aT 2?5 EC277:4 244:56?ED 5C@AA65 3J `fT[ 4@>A2C65 E@ E96 D2>6 A6C:@5 :? E96 AC6G:@FD J62C] %96C6 2C6 2=D@ D:8?D E92E 4@?86DE:@? :D =@H6C]k^Am
kAmw:52=8@[ H9@ 92D D2:5 D96 H@?’E D66< C6\6=64E:@? ?6IE J62C[ :D?’E 7:?:D965 H:E9 96C A=2?D E@ C65F46 42C EC277:4 2?5 6?4@FC286 H2=<:?8 2?5 4J4=:?8 :? !2C:D] x? 255:E:@? E@ 492C8:?8 9:896C A2C<:?8 766D 7@C $&'D[ E96 =@42= 8@G6C?>6?E 92D C6D6CG65 @?6 =2?6 @? E96 >2:? 9:89H2J 6?4:C4=:?8 E96 4:EJ 7@C AF3=:4 EC2?DA@CE 2?5 42CA@@=:?8] w6C @77:46 2=D@ 32??65 >@E@C:K65 E9C@F89\EC277:4 7C@> E96 46?E6C @7 E96 4:EJ :? }@G6>36C] {@42= H@C<6CD[ C6D:56?ED 2?5 E2I:D 2C6 DE:== 23=6 E@ 5C:G6 :?E@ E96 K@?6[ 3FE 2?J@?6 A2DD:?8 E9C@F89 E@ 8@ D@>6H96C6 6=D6 H:== 36 7:?65 €`bd WS`dbX @?46 6?7@C46>6?E 368:?D]k^Am
k9cm{@?5@?k^9cm
kAm%96 4:EJ’D F=EC2\=@H 6>:DD:@? K@?6 92D 366? :? A=246 7@C @G6C 7:G6 J62CD] %96 C6DEC:4E:@?D[ H9:49 A=246 2 52:=J 492C86 @? 5C:G:?8 @=5 82D@=:?6 @C 5:6D6= G69:4=6D[ :?:E:2==J 4@G6C65 2 D>2== 2C62 @7 E96 4:EJ 46?E6C] xE H2D DF3D6BF6?E=J 6IA2?565 E@ 4@G6C 2? 2=>@DE e__ DBF2C6 >:=6 2C62[ >2<:?8 :E E96 =2C86DE :? E96 H@C=5] {@?5@? 92D 925 2 D6A2C2E6 4@?86DE:@? 492C8:?8 K@?6[ H9:49 >62?D 2=>@DE 6G6CJ@?6 H9@ 5C:G6D :?E@ E96 4:EJ’D 4@C6 >FDE A2J[ D:?46 a__b W6=64EC:4 42CD 2C6 6I6>AE F?E:= s646>36C E9:D J62CX]k^Am
kAm(96? {@?5@? >2J@C $25:B z92? 2??@F?465 E96 6IA2?D:@? :? a_aa[ E96 564:D:@? H2D >6E H:E9 H2C?:?8D E92E 9:89 DEC66E D9@AD H@F=5 H:E96C 2H2J 2?5 D>2== 3FD:?6DD6D H@F=5 DECF88=6 E@ DFCG:G6]k^Am
kAm&{t+[ 2D E96 2C62 :D <?@H? 7@C D9@CE[ 3642>6 2 4@?E6?E:@FD E@A:4 :? =@42= 6=64E:@?D[ 2?5 z92?’D @AA@?6?E[ 7C@> E96 C:89E\H:?8 r@?D6CG2E:G6 !2CEJ[ >256 :E 2 46?EC2= A2CE @7 96C A:E49 E@ G@E6CD :? E96 >2J@C2= 6=64E:@? =2DE J62C] Wz92? H@?X]k^Am
kAmx? |2C49[ E96 >2J@C’D @77:46 C6=62D65 52E2 DF886DE:?8 E92E &{t+ 925 2 A@D:E:G6 :>A24E @? 2:C BF2=:EJ[ H9:=6 42FD:?8 =:EE=6 5:DCFAE:@? E@ D9@AD :? E96 @FED<:CED @7 {@?5@?[ 2? 2C62 H9:49 H2D @?=J :?4=F565 :? E96 K@?6 :? pF8FDE a_ab] x? A2CE:4F=2C E96 492?86 92D 4FE 6>:DD:@?D @7 ?:EC@86? @I:56D[ 2:C A@==FE2?ED =:?<65 E@ =F?8 AC@3=6>D[ 2DE9>2 2?5 :?7=2>>2E:@?[ 3J 36EH66? bbT 2?5 bhT[ H9:=6 7@@E72== 2?5 DA6?5:?8 :? D9@AD 92D ?@E 5C@AA65[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 52E2 7C@> |2DE6C42C5 x?4]k^Am
kAmp=>@DE hfT @7 G69:4=6D 5C:G6? H:E9:? E96 K@?6 2C6 ?@H 4@>A=:2?E H:E9 E96 6>:DD:@?D DE2?52C5D[ E96 C6A@CE D2:5] '2?D[ H9:49 H6C6 >F49 >@C6 =:<6=J E@ 36 42F89E FA 3J E96 492?86D[ 92G6 366? D=@H6C E@ DH:E49[ 3FE @G6C h_T 2C6 ?@H 4@>A=:2?E[ 4@>A2C65 H:E9 ;FDE `aT :? a_`f[ 367@C6 E96 K@?6 H2D :?EC@5F465]k^Am
kAm“tG6CJ@?6 :? E96 42A:E2= :D ?@H 3C62E9:?8 4=62?6C 2:C 3642FD6 @7 &{t+[� D2:5 r9C:DE:?2 r2=56C2E@[ %C2?DA@CE 7@C {@?5@?’D 5:C64E@C @7 DEC2E68J[ 4@>>6?E:?8 @? E96 C6A@CE]k^Am