PHOENIX -- Republicans who have championed school choice programs, including a voucher program allowing state money to fund private school tuition, now want to require Arizona's public school districts to let private school students compete on their sports teams.
The legislation raises a series of concerns, however, not the least of which is whether they would displace students already attending those public schools from team rosters.
kAm%96 >62DFC6 492>A:@?65 3J $6?] y@9? z2G2?289[ #\u@F?E2:? w:==D[ 4@>6D 2D D@>6 5:DEC:4ED 2C6 =6EE:?8 AC:G2E6 D49@@= DEF56?ED ;@:? E96:C =@42= 9:89 D49@@= E62>D 3FE @E96CD \\ :?4=F5:?8 9:D 9@>6 5:DEC:4E \\ 2C6 ?@E]k^Am
kAmz2G2?289 2C8F6D E92E AC:G2E6 D49@@= DEF56?ED D9@F=5 92G6 E96 D2>6 @AA@CEF?:E:6D E@ A2CE:4:A2E6 :? :?E6CD49@=2DE:4 DA@CED 2?5 @E96C 24E:G:E:6D =:<6 4=F3D 2D DEF56?ED 2EE6?5:?8 E96:C =@42= AF3=:4 D49@@= \\ :7 E96:C AC:G2E6 D49@@= 5@6D?VE @776C E9@D6 24E:G:E:6D]k^Am
kAmQtIEC24FCC:4F=2C D49@@= 24E:G:E:6D[ 36 :E 7@@E32== @C E96 496DD 4=F3[ E96JVC6 2? :>A@CE2?E A2CE @7 E96 DEF56?E’D =62C?:?8 24E:G:E:6D 2?5 2=D@ 2? :>A@CE2?E A2CE @7 E96:C >6?E2= 962=E9[Q z2G2?289 E@=5 2 w@FD6 4@>>:EE66 =2DE >@?E9]k^Am
kAm%96 >62DFC6 H2D 2AAC@G65 @? 2 G@:46 G@E6 3J E96 w@FD6 2 4@FA=6 H66<D 28@ 2?5 2H2:ED 2 7@C>2= G@E6] xE 92D 2=C625J A2DD65 E96 $6?2E6]k^Am
kAmz2G2?289 ?@E65 96 DA@?D@C65 2 =2H D6G6C2= J62CD 28@ E92E =6ED 9@>6D49@@=65 DEF56?ED ECJ @FE 7@C AF3=:4 D49@@= E62>D] w6 D2:5 AC:G2E6 D49@@= DEF56?ED D9@F=5 2=D@ 92G6 E96 @AA@CEF?:EJ]k^Am
kAmw6 D2:5 9:D 3:==[ $q `ehb[ 92D AC@E64E:@?D E@ AC6G6?E A2C6?ED 7C@> Q82>:?8 E96 DJDE6>[Q :?4=F5:?8 CF=6D D2J:?8 E96J >FDE =:G6 H:E9:? E96 3@F?52C:6D @7 E96 AF3=:4 D49@@= H96C6 E96J H2?E E96:C 49:=5C6? E@ A=2J[ E96:C 49:=5 92D E@ 92G6 A2DD:?8 8C256D 2?5 E92E E96 AC:G2E6 D49@@= E96J 2EE6?5 5@6D?VE @776C E96 DA@CE @C 24E:G:EJ] %96J�== 2=D@ ?665 E@ A2J 2?J 766D E92E 2== A=2J6CD >FDE A2J 2?5 2 AC@C2E65 D92C6 @7 E96 AC@8C2> 4@DED]k^Am
kAms6>@4C2ED 2?5 2DD@4:2E:@?D C6AC6D6?E:?8 D49@@= 5:DEC:4ED 2?5 9:89 D49@@= DA@CED 2C6 DEC@?8=J @AA@D65[ 2C8F:?8 AC:G2E6 D49@@= DEF56?ED 4@F=5 E2<6 DA@ED @? 2 E62> 2?5 5:DA=246 49:=5C6? 2EE6?5:?8 E96 AF3=:4 D49@@=]k^Am
kAmQ*@F 8FJD 42? 492?86 2 ?F>36C @7 =2HD 5@H? 96C6[ 3FE J@F 42?’E 492?86 E96 CF=6D C6=2E65 E@ 46CE2:? DA@CED[Q |2C< q2C?6D[ 2 =@33J:DE 7@C E96 pC:K@?2 $49@@= p5>:?:DEC2E@CD pDD@4:2E:@?[ E@=5 E96 w@FD6 t5F42E:@? 4@>>:EE66 5FC:?8 2 C646?E 962C:?8]k^Am
kAmQ$@446C[ E96C6VD `` A6@A=6 @? E96 7:6=5j 32D<6E32==[ 7:G6 A6@A=6 @? E96 4@FCEj 32D632==[ 6249 E62> 86ED ?:?6 A6@A=6[Q 96 D2:5] Q$@ E96C6’D 2 42A24:EJ :? 2== E96D6 AC@8C2>D[ D@ J@F 42?’E ;FDE @A6? FA E62>D E@ 2? :?7:?:E6 2>@F?E @7 A6@A=6]Qk^Am
kAmq2CCJ p2C@?D[ 2 =@33J:DE 7@C E96 pC:K@?2 x?E6CD49@=2DE:4 pDD@4:2E:@? 2?5 E96 pC:K@?2 pDD@4:2E:@? @7 $49@@= $FA6C:?E6?56?ED[ 649@65 E9@D6 H@CC:6D 2?5 E:4<65 @77 D6G6C2= @E96CD]k^Am
kAmQu:CDE[ =6E >6 E6== J@F E92E 49@:46 :D 49@:46[Q p2C@?D E@=5 E96 w@FD6 A2?6=]k^Am
kAmw6 ?@E65 E92E A2C6?ED 49@@D6 H96C6 E96:C 49:=5 8@6D E@ D49@@= 7@C 2 G2C:6EJ @7 C62D@?D \\ 2?5 D@>6E:>6D E96 D49@@= E96J 49@@D6 5@6D?VE 92G6 2 A2CE:4F=2C DA@CE]k^Am
kAm%92E’D 2 EC256@77 E96 A2C6?ED 2446AE65[ p2C@?D 2C8F65[ 2?5 7@C4:?8 2 =@42= D49@@= E96J 5@?VE 2EE6?5 E@ =6E E96> A=2J @? E62>D 2?5 <66A 2 DEF56?E 2E E92E D49@@= 7C@> A2CE:4:A2E:?8 ;FDE :D?VE 72:C]k^Am
kAmQu@F?E2:? w:==D 5:DEC:4E 92D 49@D6? ?@E E@ 2==@H E9:D[Q 96 D2:5[ C676CC:?8 E@ z2G2?289VD 4@>>F?:EJ]k^Am
kAmQ%92E :D E96:C 49@:46 2D 2 D49@@= 3@2C5[Q p2C@?D D2:5] Q|6D2 !F3=:4 $49@@=D 92D 49@D6? E@ 2==@H :E] %92E :D E96:C 49@:46]Qk^Am
kAmp2C@?D 2=D@ A@:?E65 E@ E96 8C@H:?8 ?F>36C @7 Q>:4C@D49@@=DQ 4C62E65 7@C E96 AFCA@D6 @7 2E9=6E:4 A2CE:4:A2E:@?] w6 D2:5 E9@D6 D49@@=D 4@F=5 AFE E@86E96C 2 C@DE6C @7 E@A\?@E49 A=2J6CD 2?5 E96? 86E E96> 2== E@ ECJ @FE 7@C 2 D49@@=VD E62>[ @G6CH96=>:?8 4FCC6?E A=2J6CD]k^Am
kAmz2G2?289 2C8F65 E92E A2C6?ED A2J AC@A6CEJ E2I6D E@ E96:C =@42= D49@@= 5:DEC:4E 2?5 D9@F=5 36 2==@H65 E96 36?67:ED]k^Am
kAmQ%96 A2C6?ED A2J E96 D2>6 2>@F?E @7 E2I6D 7@C :E \\ x 5@?’E <?@H H9J J@F H2?E E@ 6I4=F56 <:5D[Q z2G2?289 D2:5 5FC:?8 2 $6?2E6 962C:?8 @? E96 3:==]k^Am
kAmq2C?6D 5:D>:DD65 E96 E2I6D 2C8F>6?E] w6 ?@E65 E92E A6@A=6 A2J E2I6D E@ 7F?5 E96 4@CC64E:@?D 56A2CE>6?E[ 4@>>F?:EJ 4@==686 5:DEC:4ED 2?5 >2?J @E96C 8@G6C?>6?E 7F?4E:@?D \\ 6G6? :7 E96J 5@?’E FD6 E9@D6 D6CG:46D]k^Am
kAmQyFDE 3642FD6 D@>6@?6 A2JD E2I6D[ x 5@?’E E9:?< E92E 2=@?6 BF2=:7:6D E96> E@ 2==@H E96:C 49:=5 E@ 8@ A2CE:4:A2E6 :? 2 5:DEC:4E D49@@= DA@CE H96? E96J 92G6 49@D6? 2?@E96C D49@@=[Q q2C?6D D2:5] Q(6’C6 ?@E 6IA64E:?8 E96 AC:G2E6 D49@@=D E92E E2<6 W2 D49@@= G@F496CX E@ @A6? FA 2 DA@CE E92E E96J >2J 92G6 WE92EX 2 5:DEC:4E 5@6D?’E @776C]Qk^Am
kAm%92E C676C6?46 :D E@ E96 724E E92E pC:K@?2 @776CD G@F496CD @7 E2IA2J6C 5@==2CD A2C6?ED 42? FD6 E@ A2J EF:E:@? 2?5 6IA6?D6D 2E AC:G2E6 2?5 A2C@49:2= D49@@=D]k^Am
kAm~C:8:?2==J :?E6?565 E@ 96=A DEF56?ED H:E9 DA64:2= ?665D[ :E ?@H :D 2G2:=23=6 E@ 2== DEF56?ED[ C682C5=6DD @7 5:D23:=:E:6D @C A2C6?E2= :?4@>6[ H:E9 E96 G@F496CD DE2CE:?8 2E Sf[d__ 2 J62C] %96 4@DE E@ E2IA2J6CD ?@H 6I4665D Sg__ >:==:@?]k^Am
kAmv@G] z2E:6 w@33D 92D AC@A@D65 D42=:?8 324< 6=:8:3:=:EJ 32D65 @? A2C6?E2= :?4@>6] qFE E92E 92D AC@G6? E@ 36 2 ?@?\DE2CE6C 2>@?8 #6AF3=:42?D]k^Am
kAm%92E DE:== =62G6D E96 BF6DE:@? @7 H96E96C DEF56?ED H9@ 2C6 8@:?8 E@ AC:G2E6 D49@@=D D9@F=5 36 A2CE:4:A2E:?8 :? :?E6CD49@=2DE:4 DA@CED 2E AF3=:4 D49@@=D]k^Am
kAm$6?] r2E96C:?6 |:C2?52[ s\{2G66?[ 2D<65 z2G2?289 H96E96C 96 H2D 4@?46C?65 E92E 2 AC:G2E6 D49@@= DEF56?E H@F=5 ?@E 7:E :? H:E9 AF3=:4 D49@@= DEF56?ED H9@ <?@H 6249 @E96C 2?5 2C6 2=C625J 3@?565] z2G2?289 5:D>:DD65 E96 4@?46C?D]k^Am
kAmsFC:?8 w@FD6 5632E6 E9:D A2DE H66<[ #6A] }2?4J vFE:6CC6K[ s\%F4D@?[ A@:?E65 @FE H92E D96 D2:5 H6C6 3F:=E\:? :?6BF:E:6D :? z2G2?289VD 3:== E92E 2C6 F?72:C E@ 49:=5C6? 2EE6?5:?8 2 AF3=:4 D49@@=]k^Am
kAm$96 ?@E65 E92E 2== :E C6BF:C6D E@ D9@H AC:G2E6 D49@@= DEF56?ED 2C6 A2DD:?8 E96:C 4=2DD6D :D 2 ?@E6 7C@> E96:C A2C6?E \\ ?@E E96 7@C>2= C6G:6H @7 8C256D E92E DEF56?ED 6?C@==65 2E 2 AF3=:4 D49@@=D ?665] p?5 D96 D2:5 E96C6’D ?@E9:?8 AC6G6?E:?8 AC:G2E6 D49@@=D 7C@> ;@:?:?8 E96 pxp 2?5 7:6=5:?8 E96:C @H? DA@CED E62>D E@ 4@>A6E6 24C@DD E96 DE2E6]k^Am
kAm$@>6 2=C625J 5@]k^Am
kAmqC@A9J r@==686 !C6A2C2E@CJ[ 2 y6DF:E D49@@= :? !9@6?:I 7@C 3@JD[ :D 2? pxp >6>36C] $@ 2C6 $2=A@:?E6 r2E9@=:4 w:89 $49@@= 2?5 !FD49 #:586 r9C:DE:2? p4256>J[ 3@E9 :? %F4D@?[ 2?5 v:=36CE r9C:DE:2? $49@@=]k^Am
kAmQ(96? H6’C6 E2=<:?8 23@FE A2C6?E 49@:46 2?5 D49@@= 49@:46[ :7 J@F 49@@D6 2 D49@@= E92E 5@6D ?@E 92G6 DA@CED[ E96? E92EVD E96 D49@@= J@F 49@@D6[Q vFE:6CC6K D2:5]k^Am
kAmQ$@ :7 DA@CED :D E96 >@DE :>A@CE2?E E9:?8 E@ 2 DEF56?E[ E96J D9@F=5 49@@D6 2 D49@@= E92E 92D 2 G:3C2?E DA@CED 24E:G:EJ[Q D96 4@?E:?F65] Q%9:D :D ?@E � 92G6 J@FC 42<6 2?5 62E :E[ E@@] %9:D :D J@F 49@@D6[ 2?5 E96? J@F 86E H92E J@F 86E[ 2?5 J@F 5@?VE E9C@H 2 7:E]Qk^Am
kAm#6A] |2EE vC6DD[ #\!9@6?:I[ AFD965 324<[ ?@E:?8 E92E >2?J A2C6?ED 49@@D6 2 AC:G2E6 D49@@= 3642FD6 E96:C 49:=5 92D 2 C625:?8 567:4:E =:<6 5JD=6I:2 E96:C =@42= AF3=:4 D49@@= :D?’E 23=6 E@ 255C6DD]k^Am
kAmQx 36=:6G6 E92E E9:D :D 72C >@C6 @7 2 4@>A=:42E65 :DDF6 E92? @AA@?6?ED H@F=5 =6E @? E@[� 96 D2:5]k^Am
kAmQ$@ H96? x 962C >J 4@==628F6 � D2J[ V*@F 86E H92E J@F 86E[V D@CCJ :7 J@F 92G6 2 =62C?:?8 5:D23:=:EJ[ ?@ DA@CED 7@C J@F[ J@F 42?VE 6?8286 :? :? E96D6 :?E6CD49@=2DE:4 24E:G:E:6D[ x E9:?< E92E :D 5@H?C:89E 5:D2AA@:?E:?8[Q vC6DD D2:5] Q(6 D9@F=5 36 96=A:?8 2== <:5D :? E96 $E2E6 @7 pC:K@?2[ C682C5=6DD @7 H96C6 E96J 4@>6 7C@>[ C682C5=6DD @7 E96 D49@@= 6?G:C@?>6?E E92E E96J 2C6 :?] (6 H2?E 6G6CJ <:5 E@ E9C:G6] %92EVD H92E E9:D :D 23@FE]Qk^Am